Supporters of the Magpies are increasingly viewing their manager's side as an inconsistent friend. At their brilliant best, they prove to be the undisputed entertainers, delivering high-intensity performances. However, in other matches, once-dependable individuals like their midfield linchpin and his teammates simply go missing.
Exacerbating these problems is a second-half game management riddled with a pronounced element of disorganization. Before their trip to Manchester United, the numbers reveal a troubling picture: the team has squandered thirteen crucial top-flight points from leading positions this campaign and are without a shutout in ten consecutive games in every tournament. Securing three points at their famous stadium would constitute only their second-ever domestic success on the road this season.
In contrast, defeat has been tasted once in their previous 6 Premier League fixtures, and despite sitting in a seemingly lowly eleventh place, they remain a only 6 marks behind the highly-prized Champions League places. Consider an upcoming two-legged Carabao Cup semi-final against the reigning champions and a strong chance of advancing to the Champions League knockout phase, and it becomes simpler to appreciate the manager's cautious hope.
“It's not only about difficulties,” remarked the team's head coach. “You can see assets as well. My glass is decidedly positive at present. I understand outside observers may hold a opposing view, but in my view we are getting better.”
The puzzle is: can this squad recapture – or perhaps exceed – the successes of last season's Wembley triumph and European-qualifying finish? Balancing a congested calendar complicates.
The resulting fatigue could explain the inability to maintain a stellar opening 45-minute showing against their London rivals, eventually squandering a two-goal advantage to draw the game. Likewise, it is possibly the culprit for a subdued display in a painful defeat to arch-rivals Sunderland, where the team looked lethargic just a short time after a demanding European excursion.
While coaching is clearly the manager's strength, the constant grind of two games a week matches has drastically reduced essential coaching sessions. This impedes the team's tactical adjustment to playing with summer signing Nick Woltemade leading the line, rather than the now departed Alexander Isak. While extremely talented, the German forward has not shown the same electric counter-attacking speed or ferocious defensive work rate.
Indeed, the side's once-formidable high press has occasionally malfunctioned. Injuries to vital component the Brazilian midfielder have been a factor, while expensive signings the Swedish winger and Jacob Ramsey have found it tough settling since their big-money moves.
While a change to a 3-5-2 could arguably assist the team, a severe backline injury crisis renders that unlikely. First-choice defenders will be missing for the upcoming crucial fixtures, challenging the team's resilience.
At their high-tempo best, they seem almost unstoppable. The issue is maintaining that fervor for the entire 90 minutes. The go-to plan B of sitting back into a deep-lying defensive formation has at times been self-destructive.
“That match became disorganized at 2-2,” admitted the coach. “But the intention was going for the victory. We always go out to secure the three points.”
What seems required is a pragmatic solution – with superior possession control, a engine room adept of controlling the tempo, and a sensible readiness to occasionally accept a draw. However, a determination to compete on every fronts is stretching limited player resources to their limit.
This might sound sacrilegious to some, but a more selective approach in the domestic cups earlier could have alleviated the current schedule pile-up. With vital Champions League and league matches on the horizon, the need to strategically choose focus areas is becoming ever more apparent.
The manager acknowledged the scale of the challenge remaining. “Being involved this club, the demands are enormous. Every moment's critical. We have work to do in the Premier League. We're in the League Cup last four, we want to go through in the Europe and do well in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the correct path, but we have a great deal of work to do to become the regularly successful side we want to be. Our capacity to string together sequences of victories has deserted us so far.
“The challenge is to hit those levels we know we're capable of. I believe that the self-belief we can do that is returning. Yet now we have to prove it. It's not all bad currently, but the coming period will determine a lot.”